Showing posts with label light rail. Show all posts
Showing posts with label light rail. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

St. Matthew's to be spared?

In a stunning development, Metro light rail recently decided not to request the Phoenix City Council’s approval in May for the portion of the western extension that was slated to run from I-17 to downtown along Jefferson Street and through the St. Matthew’s neighborhood. Instead, Metro is planning to study alternative routes and the historic preservation effects of the Jefferson Street alignment for the next 6-8 months. Metro specifically mentioned that it would consider as an alternative the alignment favored by the neighborhood activists, in which the light rail follows Van Buren Street from I-17 before turning south on 19th Avenue and then heading east on Jefferson Street past the capitol and on to downtown.

While the decision certainly doesn’t guarantee anything for the St. Matthew’s neighborhood proponents who did not want to see the train run down the portion of Jefferson (between I-17 and 19th Avenue) that has historic single-family residences on either side of the street, the fact that Metro has abandoned its all-out push for approval is welcome news.

This blog applauds Metro and the Phoenix City Council for their willingness to stop and listen to the concerns of the St. Matthew’s residents. It will be interesting to see where this story goes next.

Friday, February 11, 2011

Light rail loses its way

I’ve been an unabashed supporter of light rail for years. And I still strongly support the existing line and the Mesa extension. But I cannot support the so-called western extension of the train that ADOT has proposed. Instead of moving through existing city streets and spurring economic development like the current line, the western extension is set to move along I-10 in the middle of the freeway. Essentially, ADOT is trying to turn light rail into commuter rail. I predict we’ll see busy trains at rush hour and then empty trains the rest of the time (will this line even need to run on the weekends?), and increased criticism of light rail from drivers who most of the time will zoom past empty light rail trains.

When the western extension turns off the freeway, things get even worse. Right now the train is slated to turn off I-10 and head south with I-17 on one side and a huge cemetery on the other. (Obviously, there is minimal opportunity for development.) At Jefferson, the track turns and heads down the center of a residential street until it runs by the capitol on the way to downtown. Oh, and when the light rail crosses the train track near 19th Avenue, the track apparently will need to rise some 40 feet in the air, which should be really pretty.

A much better route would have been down McDowell or Thomas over I-17 and turning at 19th Avenue down a commercial street before heading east at Jefferson and joining the original route. Apparently the current route isn’t set in stone, but this route appears to be ADOT’s favorite, and ADOT is famous for tuning out dissenting views.

The good news? This route won’t be built until 2021 at the earliest.

Friday, July 31, 2009

Elsewhere around downtown

A look at what others are saying about life in downtown and metro Phoenix:

* A group is organizing tonight to promote late-night hours on the light rail line. I took light rail after 11 p.m. on a Friday a few weeks ago and it was packed, but it's great to see others fighting complacency and helping to make sure that we don't lose our late hours.

* A state legislator gives Downtown Voices Coalition a "C+" on its report card and then receives rebuttal from a DVC member listing the group's accomplishments. I'm interested to see if the legislator responds.

* Samuel Richard at the Downtown Phoenix Journal writes about people leaving Phoenix, and draws an avalanche of responses on the topic.

* Phoenix is noticed by the Wall Street Journal, but once again it's not for reasons we'd like.

Wednesday, July 08, 2009

New Times responds to light rail ridership issue

Ray Stern, the author of the New Times light rail ridership article I discussed a few months back stopped by to comment on my post. If you recall, I suggested New Times exaggerated the state of light rail ridership and ignored the fact that Metro ridership is well above the system's own initial estimates. Ray believes I implied that it was OK for Metro to selectively report its statistics in his comment; I argue otherwise in my response.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

New Times still doesn't get light rail

Phoenix New Times has a libertarian streak that emerges from time to time in its opposition to light rail (although sadly they don’t seem to apply the same limited government philosophy to new freeway construction). This week the online version of the paper took a shot at the train, suggesting in a misleading headline that “light rail ridership [was] on decline…”

While average daily ridership in March dropped 3% from February’s numbers, there are a couple points to keep in mind. First, the March totals represented the first time average ridership has fallen, so it’s really not fair to suggest that ridership is on the decline, as if to imply some sort of trend. Perhaps this is the start of a trend as the warmer months approach, and perhaps not. We won’t know for sure until future numbers are released by Metro.

Second, and more importantly, the New Times needs to remember the baseline. For years, Metro estimated that 26,000 riders would board the train on an average day during light rail’s first year. By this measure, the train is a huge success: even the March figures (31,000+ per day) are almost 20% above the estimate. Even if ridership falls significantly during the summer, Metro is probably still a sure bet to exceed its own initial ridership estimate for the first year.

Finally, New Times is probably best-advised to avoid predicting ill fates for the light rail; the paper’s credibility in that area is somewhat shot after it ran a story last May giving the train little hope of opening on time. As we now know, light rail opened at the end of December on the exact date it announced years earlier.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Poor stadium siting decision is multi-million dollar mistake

You could laugh at the stupidity of some of the land use decisions made in the Phoenix area if they weren't so sad. Witness the struggles of Glendale and Phoenix as they try to figure out how to overcome the brutal mistake of placing University of Phoenix Stadium too far outside the urban core.

The issue reared its head as Glendale has expressed its interest in connecting the light rail system to the stadium, probably by running the train up the loop 101 from I-10. While this is a questionable decision because it uses light rail on freeways-- eliminating any opportunities for transit-oriented development on city streets, including Glendale's own downtown-- it also clearly exposes the stupidity of putting the football stadium so far away from the center of the metro area.

For those who have forgotten, Glendale ended up with the stadium after the initial site-- located in Tempe along what is now the light rail line-- was scuttled by concerns from the Federal Aviation Administration and the City of Phoenix that the stadium's proposed location in the stadium flight path was a hazard to jets taking off from the airport. The Glendale site ended up chosen almost by default as several other sites, including one in downtown Phoenix, dropped out of contention. (By the way, I have long argued that it was a positive move for downtown Phoenix that the stadium went elsewhere.)

So here we are in 2009. The stadium was built at 91st Avenue and Glendale just inside the Loop 101, where land was empty and cheap and accessible only by freeway. Meanwhile, light rail has initially proven quite successful, and places like Glendale and Mesa are clamoring for extensions into their cities. And now it's deemed a priority to bring light rail to the stadium, as Glendale and Phoenix attempt to marry the suburban, sprawled-out stadium with urban mass transit. While it's questionable how successful that arrangement will be, if it happens, there's no doubt it's going to be expensive-- the initial estimate for the additional track is $224 million.

So that's $224 million that strapped taxpayers could have avoided spending had our planners had some foresight just a few years ago and placed the stadium in Tempe or somewhere else on or near the light rail path. Hopefully future Phoenix-area land use decisions will be a little more informed now that light rail is here to stay.

Thursday, March 05, 2009

Downtown odds and ends

A well-placed source says:

* Workers will install the civic space park artwork (you know, the "jellyfish") on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday of next week.

* The Suns estimate that 10% of fans at US Airways Center arrive on light rail.

* Light rail ridership numbers in February are significantly higher than January's numbers, which beat the preliminary estimates.

* Unfortunately, 44 Monroe only has 11 contracts out of 202 units in the building. A glance at the building at night-- where only a handful of condos are lighted up-- seems to confirm that statement.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Downtown links

There's good news for downtown Phoenix as 2009 gets underway, as light rail is meeting ridership expectations so far, even before ASU, Brophy, and Central High School students return to class. In addition, despite the gloomy economic times, downtown keeps adding more entertainment options as the Irish pub called the Turf Accountant gets ready to open its doors later this month. I also understand that Club Central, the midtown hip hop spot, is opening a branch at Second Avenue and Van Buren.

On the down side: the Boston Globe (at the very end of this story) speculates that sprawled-out cities like Phoenix have less potential then dense, urban places like London or Cambridge to develop intellectual breakthroughs, or even worse, pessimistic blogger Jon Talton calls Phoenix a "dead town walking" in the midst of the recession and housing market collapse.

Wednesday, December 17, 2008

A Phoenix First

Saturday night Girlfriend_of_Downtown_Resident and I made history as we became the first people to ever miss the light rail train! Yes, I know dozens of people have already ridden the vehicle, but the two of us tried to catch the last ride on the light rail at Mayor Gordon's tree lighting and weren't able to climb aboard. Despite running up to the train-- which was full of people-- at the stop on First Avenue, the Metro representative wouldn't let us into the car. I guess I'll have to wait until December 27 to ride for real.

Saturday, October 18, 2008

Downtown links and comments

Here are a few things happening in downtown Phoenix:

* The Roosevelt Harvest Festival is today. This event, in its second year, is worth a look. It's free and it's a fun way to check out all the shops and restaurants in the area without the elbow-to-elbow hassle of First Fridays. There's even a beer garden sponsored by Lost Leaf. I went last year and enjoyed the event. My only wish for this year: hopefully the aggressive guys hawking the Obama t-shirts (their Arizona HQ is at Sixth Street) will back off a little today.

* I love the sense of humor at the light rail signs at each of the train stops around town. The small video screens show some animated flames, and then flash the words "But it's a dry heat." I wonder if this type of thing will continue once the systems's actually up and running.

* Speaking of light rail, workers at a prominent local law firm organized a light rail death pool where contestants could wager on the date and time on which the first person is killed in a light rail accident. Sick. At least the firm's top guy shut the pool down and condemned the idea.

* Finally, it's encouraging even in a down market that Sens, an Asian restaurant on First Street, will hold its grand opening this week. I doubt there's anywhere in the Phoenix area that has as many non-chain restaurant options as downtown.

Saturday, May 10, 2008

Build it

The proposed 400-foot towers at the southwest corner of Camelback and Central have everything Phoenix needs-- pedestrian orientation, height, and compatibility with the light rail line. The developer, Reid Butler, has a track record of quality downtown projects (Roosevelt Commons and Legacy Bungalows). And, in true Phoenix form, the project is meeting with resistance from the neighbors.

Protesting height is a reasonable argument in areas where the height doesn't yet exist. But Central Avenue is dotted with high-rises and has been for 30 years. Residents already live in the shadow of towers, so their arguments against this development sound weak.

The guy who really needs to get off the fence in this matter is Phoenix councilmember Tom Simplot. Light rail was built to facilitate this kind of development-- and without an ample supply of residents who can walk to its stations, Metro won't be a success. Why should this matter to Simplot? He's on Metro's board.

Saturday, March 29, 2008

Light rail appears to turn in an hour too early

Metro light rail created a stir this week when it released its schedule. Metro chose to keep its schedule simple-- they promise a train will run every ten minutes during peak hours (vaguely defined as sunrise to sunset) and twenty minutes during other times. Wade through the labrynth of light rail schedules in other cities and you'll see that this was a good idea.

But I didn't like the simultaneous announcement that the train will end service at 1 a.m. Metro rail ought to stay open until bars close at 2 a.m., especially in a county in which drunk driving is a major problem (relative to other places across the U.S.).

Metro's projected closing at 1 a.m. is early when compared to its peers*:

City Rail Service Closing Hour

New York: n/a (subway runs 24 hours)
Washington, D.C.: 3 a.m.
San Diego: 2 a.m. (last trains run around 1 a.m. and reach final stops at 2 a.m.)
Denver: 2 a.m. (last trains run around 1 a.m. and reach final stops at 2 a.m.)
Dallas: 1 a.m. (last trains run around midnight and reach final stops at 1 a.m.)
Boston: 12:30 a.m.

* It should be noted that it may be too early to know exactly what a 1 a.m. closing means. For instance, while light rail ends service at 1 a.m. in San Diego, the last train reaches its ultimate destination around 2 a.m. If at the end of the night the trains need to head to the railyard at 48th Street and Washington, it could very well be that the last train will make its way through downtown Tempe and Phoenix well after 1 a.m. We'll see.

Monday, March 12, 2007

Updates and links

Odds and ends:

New Residents. Central Phoenix's population will swell a little bit more as closings just occurred in the second building in Tapestry on Central (the portion of the complex facing Central). Meanwhile, closing is supposed to take place in mid-July in the first phase of Portland Place.

Sun Mercantile/W Hotel suit. The lawsuit filed by various groups in an effort to save the Sun Mercantile building is now rolling into its fourteenth month of existence, and still going strong. The case is now in the discovery phase. I'll say it again: developers, do quality urban projects and respect the buildings and parks that are already in place, or you will face some powerful resistance. (See 44 Monroe as an example of doing it right.)

Light rail as economic development tool. Even light rail advocates like myself will admit the project is partly about economic development. Read a libertarian response (starting on page 4).

Fellow bloggers. After perusing the sites of various downtown Phoenix-related bloggers, I have to wonder: am I the only one who's not a real estate agent?